📚 Comparison of Employment and Settlement Policies for International Students in Singapore and Shanghai | 新加坡与上海留学生就业及落户政策对比
As global mobility increases, international students face crucial decisions not only about where to study, but also where to launch their careers. Singapore and Shanghai both compete aggressively for global talent, yet their employment pass frameworks, permanent residence pathways, and settlement benefits differ significantly. This article offers a detailed side-by-side comparison to help students and graduates make informed choices.
随着全球流动性增强，留学生不仅要选择在哪里求学，更要思考在哪里开启职业生涯。新加坡与上海都在积极争夺国际人才，但两者的工作准证架构、永久居留路径以及落户福利却存在显著差异。本文提供详尽的并排比较，帮助学子和毕业生做出明智决策。
1. Overview of Employment Avenues for Graduates in Singapore | 新加坡毕业生就业途径概览
In Singapore, international students who complete a degree at a recognised institution can apply for a one-year non-renewable Long-Term Visit Pass (LTVP) after their student pass expires. This allows them to stay and seek employment without immediate employer sponsorship. Once a job offer is secured, the employer applies for a work pass, most commonly the Employment Pass (EP) or S Pass.
在新加坡，于受认可院校取得学位的国际学生，可在学生准证到期后申请为期一年、不可续签的长期访问准证（LTVP）。这让他们无需立即获得雇主担保即可居留求职。一旦获得工作录用，由雇主代为申请工作准证，最常见的是就业准证（EP）或 S Pass。
Graduates from Singapore's autonomous universities enjoy additional advantages under the 'Work Holiday Programme' or may receive a personal invitation to apply for a one-year LTVP, giving them a head start. The city-state emphasises meritocracy: the work pass you receive is tied to salary, qualifications, and the employer’s commitment.
毕业于新加坡自治大学的毕业生可享受额外优势，例如通过“工作假期计划”或收到个人化邀请申请一年期 LTVP，从而占得先机。这个城市国家强调精英制度：你获得的工作准证与薪资、学历以及雇主的承诺紧密挂钩。
2. Singapore Work Pass Types and Requirements | 新加坡工作准证类型与要求
The Employment Pass (EP) is for foreign professionals earning at least SGD 5,000 per month (higher for financial services). From September 2023, applications are assessed under the COMPASS framework, which allocates points for salary, qualifications, diversity, and support for local employment. A minimum of 40 points is required.
就业准证（EP）适用于月薪至少 5,000 新元（金融服务业更高）的外籍专业人士。自 2023 年 9 月起，申请将通过 COMPASS 框架评估，根据薪资、学历、多样性及对本地就业的支持打分，需至少获得 40 分。
The S Pass targets mid-skilled technical staff with a minimum salary of SGD 3,150. It is subject to a quota (currently 10% of the workforce in the services sector) and a monthly levy. For fresh graduates, the EP is the main target, but some may start on an S Pass if they do not yet meet EP criteria.
S Pass 面向中级技能技术人员，最低月薪为 3,150 新元。它受配额限制（服务业目前为员工总数的 10%）并需缴纳月度外劳税。对刚毕业的学生而言，EP 是主要目标，但若暂未满足 EP 条件，部分人可能先持 S Pass 入职。
Graduates can also consider the Tech.Pass for highly accomplished tech entrepreneurs, or the EntrePass for those starting a business. However, these are less common for typical fresh graduates.
毕业生还可考虑面向成就卓越的科技创业者的 Tech.Pass，或创办企业者适用的 EntrePass。不过，这些在典型应届生中并不常见。
3. Singapore Permanent Residence (PR) Pathways for Graduates | 新加坡留学生转永久居民（PR）路径
International students can apply for Permanent Residence (PR) while still studying if they have resided in Singapore for more than two years and have passed at least one national exam (e.g., PSLE, GCE N/O/A Levels). For those who only completed a degree, the route typically involves working for 6-12 months on an EP or S Pass before applying under the Professionals/Technical Personnel and Skilled Workers (PTS) scheme.
国际学生在就读期间，若已在新加坡居住超过两年且通过至少一项国家级考试（如 PSLE、GCE N/O/A 水准），即可申请永久居民（PR）。对于仅完成学位课程者，路线通常是持 EP 或 S Pass 工作 6 至 12 个月后，通过专业人士/技术人员与熟练工人计划（PTS）提出申请。
Key factors for PR approval include salary level, duration of stay, economic contribution, and family ties. There is no quota, but the process is discretionary. PR status offers subsidised education, healthcare, and a shorter path to citizenship. However, male PRs are liable for National Service.
PR 获批的关键因素包括薪资水平、居住时长、经济贡献及家庭纽带。虽无名额上限，但审核属酌情性质。PR 身份可享受教育津贴、医疗补贴，并缩短入籍路径。但男性 PR 需承担国民服役义务。
4. Shanghai Employment Landscape and Work Visa Requirements | 上海就业市场与工作签证要求
In Shanghai, foreign graduates seeking employment typically need a work permit and a Z visa. The employer must be qualified to hire foreign nationals. Graduates can be hired directly if they meet the criteria under China's classification system: Category A (high-end talent), Category B (professional personnel), or Category C (other). Most fresh graduates fall into Category B, requiring a bachelor's degree and two years of relevant work experience, though this requirement can be waived for certain top graduates from world-class universities.
在上海，外籍毕业生求职通常需取得工作许可和 Z 签证。用人单位须具备聘用外国人资质。毕业生若满足中国分类体系标准，可直接受聘：A 类（高端人才）、B 类（专业人才）或 C 类（其他）。多数应届生属 B 类，要求学士学位及两年相关工作经验，但对于世界一流大学的优秀毕业生，该工作经验要求可豁免。
Shanghai encourages innovation through a 'Foreigner's Work Permit for Innovation and Entrepreneurship' for those starting a tech-based business. Additionally, graduates from overseas universities can apply for a one-year residence permit for job-seeking purposes if they graduate from a top 500 global university within two years, following the 'Foreign High-Level Talent Confirmation Letter' route.
上海鼓励创新，针对创办科技企业者可颁发“外国人创新创业工作许可”。此外，海外高校毕业生若毕业于世界排名前 500 院校且在两年内，可循“外籍高层次人才确认函”途径申请为期一年的求职居留许可。
5. Shanghai Hukou Settlement Policy for Overseas Returnees | 上海海外留学回国人员落户政策
Shanghai has one of China's most attractive hukou (household registration) policies for overseas returnees. The core requirement: the graduate must have obtained a degree from a recognised overseas institution and must come to Shanghai to work within two years after returning to China. The employer must be registered in Shanghai and pay social insurance in accordance with the law.
上海拥有中国最具吸引力的留学回国人员落户（户口）政策之一。核心要求：毕业生须从受认可的海外院校获得学位，并须在回国后两年内来上海工作。用人单位须在上海注册并依法缴纳社会保险。
ing hired in Shanghai, and they can directly apply for hukou. Those from top 51-100 universities need only six months of social insurance, with no base requirement. For other recognised universities, the standard route requires six months of contributions at 1× the average social salary (currently around RMB 12,183), or 12 months at 1.5× for non-key university graduates.
社保缴费基数起着关键作用。对于世界排名前 50 院校的毕业生，在上海受聘后可免工作经验直接申请落户。排名 51-100 院校的毕业生只需缴纳 6 个月社保，无基数要求。其他认可院校，标准路径需连续 6 个月按 1 倍社平工资缴纳社保（目前基数约 12,183 元），非重点院校毕业生则需 12 个月 1.5 倍基数。
Shanghai also offers a streamlined 'direct settlement' for overseas doctoral degree holders who are working in Shanghai, with no social insurance duration requirement, making it an exceptionally fast track.
上海还为在沪工作的海外博士学位持有者提供“直接落户”通道，无社保时长要求，可谓极速通道。
6. Eligibility Criteria Comparison: Degree and Institution Ranking | 资格标准对比：学位与院校排名
| Factor | Singapore | Shanghai |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum degree for EP/Hukou | Bachelor's from recognised institution; strong preference for local autonomous universities | Bachelor's from recognised overseas institution (verified by Ministry of Education) |
| Institution ranking impact | Not directly tied to EP, but COMPASS awards points for qualifications from top-tier institutions; PR considerations may factor in institution prestige | Very significant: Top 50, 51-100, and other lists determine social insurance period and base waiver |
| Work experience requirement | None for EP; but COMPASS may require points else compensated by salary/qualifications | Generally 2 years for Category B work permit, waivable for top graduates; no work experience for hukou application itself |
The above table illustrates a clear contrast: Singapore's system evaluates the overall profile through points, while Shanghai prescribes distinct tiers based on university rankings. This means a graduate from a lower-ranked university may find an easier hukou path in Shanghai if they managed to negotiate a higher salary, but in Singapore, a high salary can compensate for a non-top-tier degree in the COMPASS scoring.
上表勾勒出鲜明对比：新加坡的体系通过打分全面评估，而上海则依据院校排名划出清晰梯队。这意味着，排名较后院校的毕业生若能在上海协商到较高薪资，可能获得更便捷的落户路径；而在新加坡，高薪资同样可在 COMPASS 评分中弥补非顶尖学位的劣势。
7. Salary Thresholds and Cost of Living Considerations | 薪资门槛与生活成本考量
Singapore's EP minimum salary of SGD 5,000 (about USD 3,700) is substantially higher than Shanghai's implicit requirement for hukou – y RMB 12,183, or USD 1,680). However, living costs in Singapore are markedly higher: rental for a one-bedroom condo in a non-central area can be SGD 2,500-3,500, while in Shanghai, a comparable apartment may cost RMB 6,000-10,000.
新加坡 EP 的最低薪资 5,000 新元（约 3,700 美元）远高于上海落户隐含的社保基数要求——1 倍社平工资（约 12,183 元人民币，或 1,680 美元）。然而，新加坡的生活成本明显更高：非核心区一居室公寓租金可达 2,500-3,500 新元，而上海类似公寓可能只需 6,000-10,000 元人民币。
Graduates should also consider that Shanghai's social insurance contribution is mandatory and deducted from salary, whereas Singapore's Central Provident Fund (CPF) contributions only kick in after obtaining PR; before that, no mandatory retirement savings are deducted. Thus, net disposable income may feel higher in Singapore initially, but long-term retirement benefits differ.
毕业生还应考虑，上海的社会保险是强制缴纳并从工资扣除，而新加坡的中央公积金（CPF）仅在取得 PR 后才开始缴纳；在此之前没有强制退休储蓄扣除。因此，初期在新加坡的可支配收入可能感觉更高，但长期退休福利存在差异。
8. Processing Timelines and Application Complexity | 办理时间与申请复杂度
In Singapore, an EP application can be processed within 3 weeks, and the LTVP for graduates is usually granted within 2-4 weeks. PR applications, however, take 4-12 months and involve extensive documentation including employment history, educational certificates, and a personal statement. There is no appeal process; rejected applicants must wait a recommended period before reapplying.
在新加坡，EP 申请可在 3 周内办结，毕业生 LTVP 通常在 2-4 周内获批。但 PR 申请需要 4-12 个月，并涉及大量文件：工作履历、学历证明及个人陈述。无申诉机制；被拒者须等待推荐期限后方可重新申请。
Shanghai's hukou application for overseas returnees is surprisingly streamlined: online submission, document verification, and approval within 15 working days after physical submission of original documents. The pre-application social insurance accumulation period is the real timeline; for world top 50 graduates, it is instant, while for others it is 6-12 months. The work permit process for initial employment takes 15-20 working days.
上海留学回国人员落户的申请流程出奇简化：线上提交、核验材料、现场交原件后 15 个工作日内审批。真正的耗时在于前置的社保累积期：世界前 50 院校毕业生即时光速办理，其他人则需 6-12 个月。初次就业的工作许可办理约需 15-20 个工作日。
9. Benefits Attached to Settlement Status | 身份附带的福利对比
Singapore PR holders gain access to subsidised public housing (after fulfilling ethnic integration policy and waiting periods), subsidised education for children, and enhanced employment flexibility. However, they are not eligible to vote and must serve National Service (for males). After two years of PR, one may apply for citizenship, which grants a powerful passport and full rights.
新加坡 PR 持有人可获得公共住房津贴（需满足种族融合政策与等候期）、子女教育补贴及更高的就业灵活度。但他们无投票权，且男性须服兵役。PR 满两年后可申请公民身份，从而获得全球通行力强的护照与完全权利。
Shanghai hukou is effectively a local citizenship within the city, granting access to free public education for children, eligibility to purchase property without the usual 5-year tax requirement (though restrictions may still apply), and access to the city's social benefits like the medical insurance system. Importantly, hukou offers a permanent right to reside without visa renewal.
上海户口实质上是城市内部的“身份”，赋予子女免费公立教育资格、不受限购政策中 5 年社保要求购房（虽仍可能有其他限制），以及享受城市医保等社会福利。至关重要的是，户口提供无须签证续签的永久居留权。
10. Flexibility and Portability of Status | 身份的灵活性与便携性
Singapore PR must maintain a Re-Entry Permit (REP) if they travel out of Singapore while retaining PR status. A valid REP is required to re-enter as a PR. If absent for prolonged periods without a valid REP, PR can be revoked. There is no requirement to reside for a minimum number of days annually, but PR renewal is assessed on economic contribution and ties.
新加坡 PR 若要在保留身份的同时离境，须持有有效的再入境许可（REP）。若无有效 REP 而长期缺席，PR 身份可能被撤销。虽无每年最低居住天数要求，但 REP 续签会根据经济贡献与联系评估。
Shanghai hukou, in contrast, is permanent and does not require renewal. Once settled, even if the holder works abroad for an extended period, the hukou is not revoked. However, if a hukou holder obtains foreign nationality, the hukou may be cancelled as China does not recognise dual nationality.
上海户口则具永久性，无需续签。落户后，即使持有人长期在海外工作，户口也不会被撤销。但若户口持有人取得外国国籍，由于中国不承认双重国籍，户口可能被注销。
11. Recent Policy Updates and Strategic Considerations | 近期政策动态与策略考量
Singapore introduced the COMPASS framework in 2023 and raised EP salary thresholds in 2025, signalling a tightening of immigration. However, it remains committed to attracting young, high-earning talent. Shanghai, on the other hand, has continuously relaxed hukou rules: in 2024 it expanded the list of top 100 universities and further streamlined the application process, reflecting a drive to boost population and consumption.
新加坡于 2023 年推出 COMPASS 框架，并在 2025 年提高 EP 薪资门槛，释放收紧移民的信号。但仍致力于吸引年轻的高收入人才。上海方面则持续放宽落户规则：2024 年扩大了前 100 院校名录，并进一步简化申请流程，反映出提振人口与消费的意图。
For a student choosing between the two, it is crucial to map their career trajectory. Singapore offers a faster path to a globally recognised citizenship but with higher immediate earnings pressure. Shanghai provides a relatively secure and permanent status with lower barriers for top graduates, yet the long-term career and travel flexibility might differ.
对在两者间抉择的学生而言，规划职业生涯轨迹至关重要。新加坡提供更快捷的全球认可公民身份路径，但即期收入压力较大。上海则为顶尖毕业生提供相对稳固且永久的身份，门槛较低，但长期职业与出行灵活性或有不同。
12. Conclusion: Matching Policies to Personal Goals | 结语：将政策与个人目标匹配
Both Singapore and Shanghai present clear, merit-based frameworks for international students to transition from study to settlement. Singapore's EP-COMPASS and PR system reward economic integration and demand patience and high remuneration. Shanghai's hukou policy for returnees offers a predictable, tiered timeline that aggressively favours graduates from prestigious institutions.
新加坡和上海都为留学生从学业到安居提供了清晰、基于能力的框架。新加坡的 EP-COMPASS 与 PR 体系奖励经济融合，需要耐心与高薪酬。上海的留学回国人员落户政策则给出可预测的分层时间表，显著青睐名校毕业生。
Ultimately, the decision should be anchored not just on paper policies but on industry opportunities, lifestyle preferences, and family considerations. Students are encouraged to consult official immigration authority portals and career services at their universities for the most current details.
最终决策不应仅停留在纸面政策，而应植根于行业机遇、生活偏好和家庭考量。鼓励学子查阅官方移民局门户及所在大学职业服务中心，获取最新信息。
Published by TutorHao | Career & Settlement Policies Revision Series | aleveler.com
更多咨询请联系16621398022（同微信）
或截图后用「扫一扫 → 相册」选择本图