替代学生贷款 ASF 穆斯林学生 贡献金
英国的学生贷款都带利息，这一条规则把一部分人挡在了门外。英国教育部在 gov.uk 的官方页面上写明，有些学生会因为信仰或良心而无法使用现有的学生贷款，这种情况在部分穆斯林身上最常见，因为他们的信仰不允许与利息打交道。教育部因此承诺推出一个不用利息的学生金融产品，英文叫 alternative student finance，简称 ASF。这篇文章把官方口径、立法依据与 2019 年教育部委托的定性研究放在一起看，也就是穆斯林学生对现有贷款体系和替代方案的真实看法。
In England every student loan carries interest, and that single feature keeps some people out of the system. The Department for Education states on gov.uk that some students feel unable to use existing student loans because of their faith or conscience, most often some Muslims whose religion prohibits dealing with interest. The government has therefore committed to a product that avoids interest, known as alternative student finance, or ASF, and this article brings the official position, the legal basis and the department's own 2019 research together.
利息禁令与英国学生贷款的冲突
英国所有学生贷款都收利息，这是官方页面开头的原话。伊斯兰金融的起点判断是钱本身没有内在价值，只是一种交换媒介。靠借钱收利息，或者收回比本金更多的钱，在阿拉伯语里叫 riba，被明确禁止。贷款机构拿资金去做投资，如果投向赌博或酒类行业，会被视为同一类问题。在 2012 年之后签的 Plan 2 贷款，利率一般是 RPI 再加最多 3%。对 2023 年起的新借款人来说，最高利率又回到只跟 RPI 走。很多学生以为利息只是多还一点钱，对一部分家庭来说，它是能不能签字的问题。
Every student loan in England carries interest, which is the first line of the official page. Islamic finance starts from the position that money has no intrinsic value and is only a medium of exchange; charging interest, or receiving back more than was lent, is known as riba and is forbidden, and money placed by lenders in gambling or alcohol businesses raises the same objection. Plan 2 loans taken out after 2012 generally charge RPI plus up to 3%, while the maximum rate for borrowers from 2023 is set back at RPI alone.
2014 年征求意见设下的四条设计底线
政府在 2014 年 4 月就一个符合沙里亚规则的替代融资产品启动了公开征求意见。当时的方案由商务、创新与技能部推动，并在征求意见时立了四条底线。毕业后要还的钱和债务规模必须与现行学生贷款完全一致。还款过程要和现在一样方便。申请入口必须还是通过学生贷款公司。产品的运作方式要透明，学生自己能看懂。这四条后来一直没变，也解释了为什么官方在每一版说明里都强调这条路既不吃亏也不占便宜。政策制定的顺序是先定底线，再谈宗教合规，最后才是技术实现。
The consultation on a Sharia-compliant alternative finance product opened in April 2014 and set four conditions that still shape every later version of the model. Repayments and debt levels after graduation had to be identical to those of current student loans, making repayments had to be just as easy, the product had to be applied for through the Student Loans Company in the same way, and it had to be transparent enough for students to understand how it works. Those conditions explain the line the government keeps repeating now, namely that nobody should gain or lose by choosing this route.
2017 年法案第 86 与 87 条的立法授权
立法层面的突破发生在 2017 年。这部法案的第 86 与 87 条把这个设想变成法律权力，允许政府引入一种不带利息的学生资助模式，官方称之为 alternative payments。随法案公布的影响评估在第 203 至 219 页列出预期收益。它说这能替因宗教原因不愿借款的人移除升学障碍，毕业生数量增加会带来更多所得税与国民保险收入，还能缓解雇主的技能短缺。有权力不等于产品已经存在。英国议会下议院图书馆的研究简报记录，2019 年 7 月上议院还专门辩论过为什么迟迟没有落地。
The legal turning point came in 2017, when the Higher Education and Research Act created the power to introduce an additional model of student finance called alternative payments, which carries no interest. The impact assessment published with the bill set out the expected benefits on pages 203 to 219, including the removal of a barrier to higher education for people unwilling to borrow for religious reasons, higher income tax and National Insurance receipts from a larger graduate population, and relief for employers facing skills shortages. A power is not a product, and the House of Commons Library briefing records that the Lords debated the delay in July 2019.
2019 年教育部研究：77 名受访者
教育部在 2019 年 5 月 30 日公布了一份研究报告，题目是 Alternative Student Finance: current and future students' perspectives，报告编号 DFE-RR915，共 88 页。研究方法把访谈与焦点小组结合起来，一共 77 位穆斯林学生、毕业生和潜在学生参加，另外还做了文献回顾和对学生收入与支出调查数据的描述性分析。研究要回答三个问题。他们对借钱和负债抱什么态度。信仰与资金在他们的高等教育决定里起什么作用。他们对当时提议的 ASF 模型怎么看、会不会用。这也是目前唯一一份由政府部门直接委托的、针对这个产品的定性研究。
The department published the study on 30 May 2019 under the title Alternative Student Finance: current and future students' perspectives, reference DFE-RR915, running to 88 pages. Its method combined one-to-one interviews with focus groups, involving 77 Muslim students, graduates and potential students, alongside a literature review and a descriptive analysis of the Student Income and Expenditure Survey dataset. Three questions shaped the work, namely what participants thought about borrowing and debt, what role faith and money played in their decisions about higher education, and how they viewed the proposed ASF model, which remains the only qualitative study of this product commissioned directly by a government department.
债务感与信仰怎样影响贷款决定
报告最被引用的一条结论与预测因素有关。信仰和对债务的态度，是判断一个人会不会申请学生贷款时最重要的两个变量。非穆斯林表示自己会考虑贷款的可能性，是穆斯林受访者的三倍半，数据写在报告第 132 页。访谈里，受访者把利息描述为不被允许、或者至少应当避开的东西。有人提到在特定情况下借款也许可以被接受，也有人承认自己对金融的理解会随年龄和处境变化。对伊斯兰金融产品的了解普遍有限，市场上能真正用得上的产品也少。家庭与文化的影响、宗教的影响同时出现在他们的讲述里，两者并不容易分开。
The study's most quoted finding concerns prediction, because religion and attitudes to debt were the strongest factors in whether someone expected to take a student loan; non-Muslims were three and a half times more likely than Muslims to anticipate doing so, as recorded on page 132. Participants described interest as something not permissible, or at least to be avoided, while some said borrowing could be acceptable in particular situations and others accepted that their own understanding of finance had changed over time. Awareness of Islamic finance products was limited and the products themselves scarce, and family and cultural influences ran alongside religious ones rather than separately.
不用贷款的学生怎么负担学费与生活费
报告里有一个容易被忽略的反差。穆斯林学生对债务更反感，但他们进入高等教育的比例仍然高于非穆斯林。研究把原因落在三件事上，就是更可能有储蓄，更倾向选本地大学，读书期间更可能住在家里。这样一来，资金压力不一定表现为不上大学，而是表现为选择被压缩。住得远、通勤时间长、打工占掉的时间、被排除在外的高学费城市与专业，都是同一笔账的不同写法。常见的错误是把他们还是上了大学当成资金不构成障碍的证据，实际上代价已经转移到了别的地方。
A contrast in the study is easy to miss, because Muslim students were more debt averse yet still more likely to enter higher education than non-Muslims. The report puts this down to three things happening together, namely a greater likelihood of having savings, a stronger preference for a local university, and a greater chance of living at home while studying. The financial constraint therefore did not always show up as staying out of university; it showed up as a narrower set of choices about where to live, how long to commute, how many hours to work and which courses remained realistic.
研究记录的取舍：放弃入学与压缩选择
报告把受访者按资金来源分成两组来写，一组用了学生贷款，一组没有用。不用贷款的那组要自己拼出学费与生活费，来源包括家庭支持、储蓄、兼职收入以及本地就近入学的安排。研究记录到有人因为不愿意借带利息的钱而决定不进高等教育。它也记录到另一些人的选择被压缩，例如放弃远离家乡的学校。报告同时提醒，学生金融并不是唯一的考虑因素，课程、家庭期待、成绩与距离都在起作用。在信息渠道方面，学校和学院被认为是最重要的来源，互联网、社交媒体、社区团体与家人也在影响判断。
The report splits participants by how their studies were funded, looking separately at those who used a student loan and those who did not. The second group had to assemble tuition and living costs from family support, savings, part-time earnings and a decision to stay local, and the research records both people who decided against higher education because they would not borrow at interest and others whose choices narrowed, for instance by ruling out universities far from home. Student finance was not the only consideration, since the course itself, family expectations, grades and distance all carried weight, and schools and colleges emerged as the most important source of information ahead of the internet, social media, community groups and family.
Takaful 互助与伊斯兰金融监督委员会
官方页面在 2025 年 6 月 9 日更新后，把产品结构写得清楚了。新体系会由一个独立的伊斯兰金融专家委员会认证合规，这个委员会叫 Islamic Finance Supervisory Board。产品使用伊斯兰金融中的 Takaful 原则，提供一种群体互助式的支持，而不是学生与放贷机构之间的两方借贷。英国教育部已委托 Islamic Finance Council UK 担任秘书处，由它来任命并支持这个独立监督委员会，认证工作的具体信息可以在该机构官网查到。教育部在 2025 年 6 月的博客里把这个产品描述为世界上最早由政府背书、并符合伊斯兰金融原则的学生贷款方案之一。
The official page was updated on 9 June 2025 and now sets out the structure more clearly, with compliance certified by an independent board of Islamic finance specialists called the Islamic Finance Supervisory Board. The product will use the principle of Takaful, providing group-based mutual support rather than a two-party loan between a student and a lender, and the Department for Education has appointed the Islamic Finance Council UK as secretariat to run the certification. A June 2025 post on the department's Education Hub described ASF as one of the first state-backed student loan schemes in the world compatible with Islamic finance.
替代支付与贡献金的还款机制
申请环节在官方说明里被刻意保持简单。任何符合学生金融资格的本科生都可以用 ASF，不限信仰，也不需要额外证明。申请人申请的是学费与生活费的 alternative payment，替代原来的带息贷款，入口仍然是 Student Finance England。离校之后要还的东西不叫还款，叫 contributions。这笔钱会被专款专用，只用来为之后的学生提供 ASF，不会进入一般财政。官方还写明，贡献金的计算只看收入，不看当初拿了多少。走这条路的学生既不会因此吃亏，也不会因此占便宜。
The application process is deliberately kept simple in the official description, because ASF will be open to any undergraduate eligible for student finance, whatever their faith. Applicants will request an alternative payment for both tuition fees and living costs instead of an interest-bearing loan, applying through Student Finance England in the same way as a traditional loan, and after leaving study they make contributions equal in amount and timing to the repayments made by mainstream borrowers. Those contributions are ringfenced so the money can only fund ASF for later students, and the amount is based on what a person earns rather than on what they received.
终身学习权益之后的时间表
官方的理由是顺序问题。ASF 必须与主流学生金融对齐，所以它只能在终身学习权益上线之后尽快推出。终身学习权益的英文缩写是 LLE，它从 2026 到 2027 学年开始实施，取代现行的后 18 岁学生金融体系。政府在 2026 年公布的《终身学习（学费上限）条例》说明文件重申了承诺。原话是不让任何学生因为信仰而无法获得高等教育的学生金融，并说明实施 ASF 的二级立法会连同单独的平等性分析一并公布。到 2026 年 10 月为止，官方页面没有给出确定的启用日期。教育部在 2026 年 4 月的市场征询公告里透露了正在处理的技术细节，就是需要一个可以合规持有与划转资金的银行账户，而且账户本身不得产生或收取利息。
Timing comes down to sequencing, because ASF has to mirror mainstream student finance and can therefore only arrive as soon as possible after the Lifelong Learning Entitlement replaces the post-18 funding system from the 2026 to 2027 academic year. The explanatory note to the Lifelong Learning (Fee Limits) Regulations 2026, SI 2026/856, repeats the commitment that no student should be excluded from higher education finance because of faith, and states that secondary legislation implementing ASF will be published alongside a separate equalities analysis. No launch date had been confirmed as of October 2026, although an April 2026 market engagement notice from the department showed that the banking arrangements are actively being designed, including an account that can hold and move funds without bearing or generating interest.
研究提出的顾虑：总债务与基金治理
报告在正面反应之外记录了具体的疑问。最集中的两点是总债务规模，以及这笔钱由谁管理、怎么管。受访者对最后要还多少比对利率是多少更敏感，因为在他们看来问题从来不只是利息本身。基金治理的疑问包括资金是否真的只用于学生、账目能否看懂、以及规则改变时谁来兜底。研究还提到利益相关者的接受度问题。产品要被认为可信，需要的不只是技术合规，还需要社区里被信任的人公开表态。这些顾虑至今仍然是解释 ASF 时最难讲清楚的部分。
Alongside the positive reaction, the study recorded specific doubts, with total debt the sharpest concern followed by how the fund would be managed and by whom. Participants were more sensitive to the amount they would eventually owe than to the rate applied, because for them interest was never the only issue. Questions about governance covered whether the money really would be used only for students, whether the accounts could be understood, and who would step in if the rules changed, and the research also flagged acceptance by stakeholders, since credibility depends on trusted voices in the community speaking up rather than on technical compliance alone.
社区内部差异与产品宣传口径
报告最后一层的提醒与穆斯林社区这个说法有关。研究指出社区内部在教派、文化背景、家庭处境和对金融的理解上差别很大。把所有人当成同一种顾虑来处理，会让一部分人觉得产品不是为自己设计的。宗教权威的态度被受访者反复提到，学者说可以，才会有人真的去申请。在宣传口径上，报告建议把 ASF 呈现为对所有学生开放的选择，而不是一个只面向特定群体的特殊通道，这一点和官方任何人都可以用的表述是一致的。对准备申请的学生，现实一点的做法是先确认自己的资格类型，再盯住 gov.uk 上的 ASF 页面与 Student Finance England 的申请入口，因为在这个产品正式开放之前，官方路径仍然只有带利息的贷款。
The final layer of the report concerns the very phrase Muslim community, because participants came from different traditions, cultural backgrounds and family situations, and treating them as a single audience with one set of concerns would leave some feeling the product was not designed for them. The endorsement of religious scholars came up repeatedly, since many said they would only apply once scholars confirmed the scheme was acceptable, and the study therefore recommended presenting ASF as a route open to all students rather than a special channel for one group. That matches the official wording that any student eligible for student finance can use it.
牛津高阶英汉双解词典 第10版 商务印书馆¥168📱 去京东购买京东精选需要一对一辅导？Need One-on-One Tutoring?
A-Level / GCSE / IB / KS2-KS3 全科辅导
16621398022 同微信
Visit aleveler.com
或截图后用「扫一扫 → 相册」选择本图