QS Stars 评级 与 QS 排名 区别 A-Level 选校

QS Stars 评级 与 QS 排名 区别 A-Level 选校

申请季里，很多学生和家长把 QS 排名当成选校的唯一标尺，看到心仪的学校排在第 200 名就犹豫，看到第 60 名就下单。QS 其实有两套工具：一套是大家熟悉的 QS 世界大学排名，另一套叫 QS Stars，是星级评级。前者回答"谁排在前面"，后者回答"这所学校好在哪里"。这篇文章把两套体系的差别、星级怎么打分、以及 A-Level 学生该怎么用，一次讲清楚。

Every application season, students and parents treat the QS World University Rankings as the single yardstick for choosing a university. QS runs two separate tools. The World University Rankings compare institutions and place them in order, while QS Stars works as an audit that rates a university against global standards covering teaching, employability, governance and facilities. This article sets out how the two systems differ, how stars are awarded, and how A-Level applicants can use a rating alongside course entry requirements.

一、评级不是排名：QS Stars 在评什么 / Rating, Not Ranking

QS Stars 在 2009 年推出，据 QS 自己的方法论文件（QS Stars Methodology，v6.0，2024 版），目前已有 700 多所院校完成评估。它最关键的一点是不把院校互相排序。官方对两者的区分说得很直白：排名回答"谁表现最好"，评级回答"谁在哪方面强"。参评是自愿的，官方称 opt-in，因此参评院校数量没有上限，一所国际声望远不如罗素集团成员的学校，也可能在教学、设施、就业服务上拿到 5 星。结论分两层：一个总评，从 1 星到 5+ 星；以及每个类别的星级，从 1 星到 5 星。

QS Stars launched in 2009, and according to QS's own methodology document, version 6.0 published in 2024, more than 700 institutions have now been evaluated. The key difference is that it does not rank universities against one another. QS states the split plainly: a ranking shows who has performed best, while a rating shows who is good at what. Participation is opt-in, so there is no cap on how many institutions can take part, and a university with a modest global profile can still earn five stars for teaching, facilities or career support. Results come in two layers. There is an overall badge from one star to five plus stars, and there is a star rating for each individual category.

二、审计怎么打分：必修类别与总分门槛 / How Points Become Stars

一次标准审计覆盖必修类别，并允许院校在两个自选类别中参评，最终至少得到九个类别的星级加一个总评。必修的有教学（Teaching）、设施或线上教学（Facilities / Online learning）、社会影响或环境影响、科研或学术发展（Research / Academic development）、全球参与（Global engagement）、就业力（Employability）、治理（Good governance）。分数按指标折算：教学、就业力、科研这类满分 150 分的类别，5 星要 105 分；设施、治理这类满分 100 分的类别，5 星要 70 分。总评门槛更高，700 分以上才是 5 星，而且要同时满足教学 105 分、就业力 85 分、国际师资与国际学生各占 5% 等前置条件；900 分以上并且每个类别都拿到 5 星，才够 5+ 星。数据由院校提交，QS 会指派专属分析师核对第三方来源。

A standard audit covers the mandatory categories plus two elective ones the institution chooses, producing ratings in at least nine categories and an overall result. The mandatory areas are teaching, facilities or online learning, social or environmental impact, research or academic development, global engagement, employability and good governance. Points are scaled from indicators. In the 150-point categories such as teaching, employability and research, five stars requires 105 points, while the 100-point categories such as facilities and governance need 70 points for five stars. The overall badge is harder to reach. Seven hundred points is the floor for five stars, and the prerequisites include 105 points in teaching, 85 points in employability, and at least five per cent international faculty and international students. Only 900 points with five stars in every category reaches five plus stars. Universities submit the data, and QS assigns a dedicated analyst who validates third-party evidence.

三、QS 世界大学排名 2026 版看什么 / Inside the Ranking Methodology

QS 世界大学排名 2026 版在 2025 年 6 月发布，覆盖 105 个国家和地区的 1,504 所院校。它的 9 项指标里，学术声誉占 30%，雇主声誉占 15%，两项问卷合计 45%，接近总分的一半；其余是师均引用 20%、师生比 10%，国际师资、国际学生、国际研究网络、就业结果、可持续性各 5%。这就是排名与评级最实际的区别：排名给的是国际能见度与科研体量的快照，评级给的是具体维度的体检报告。QS 官网在 2025 年 11 月的说明里提到，58% 的受访学生表示愿意考虑排名较低、但在关键维度表现强劲的学校。

The QS World University Rankings 2026 edition was released in June 2025 and covers 1,504 institutions across 105 countries and regions. Nine indicators feed the score. Academic reputation carries 30 per cent and employer reputation 15 per cent, so survey opinion supplies 45 per cent of the total, close to half. Citations per faculty take 20 per cent and the faculty-student ratio 10 per cent, while international faculty, international students, international research network, employment outcomes and sustainability take 5 per cent each. That is the practical difference between the two tools. A ranking is a snapshot of global visibility and research scale, whereas a rating is closer to a health check on specific dimensions. QS noted in a November 2025 article that 58 per cent of students polled said they would consider a lower-ranked university that performs strongly in the areas they care about.

四、A-Level 申请者最该看的四个类别 / Four Categories Worth Your Attention

对 A-Level 申请者来说，有四个类别的星最值得逐项看。教学（Teaching）里的师生比、学生满意度、完成率与升学率，对应的是你未来三年会不会被放养；就业力（Employability）看雇主声誉、就业结果与就业服务，打算毕业就工作或做实习的学生重点看这里；全球参与（Global engagement）看国际师资、国际学生比例与交换项目，影响的是你能不能有一段真实的海外经历；设施或线上教学看住宿、图书馆支出、体育设施，或线上课程的支撑程度。很多学生会忽略一点：这些指标是院校层面的平均值，你要读的具体专业可能比平均值强，也可能更弱。

For A-Level applicants, four categories deserve the closest look. Teaching covers the faculty-student ratio, student satisfaction, completion and progression to further study, which indicates how much attention you are likely to receive. Employability covers employer reputation, graduate outcomes and career services, and it matters most if you plan to work or take internships soon after graduation. Global engagement covers international faculty and students plus exchange programmes, and it shapes whether you get a genuine overseas experience. Facilities or online learning covers accommodation, library spending, sport facilities and the support behind online delivery. One detail students often miss is that these are institution-wide averages, and the specific course you apply for may sit above or below that average.

五、把评级用在选校上的正确顺序 / Requirements First, Stars Second

把评级用在选校上，顺序应该是先过官方硬门槛，再看强项，最后看国际能见度。先打开 UCAS 和具体课程的入学要求（entry requirements），确认你的 A-Level 科目与预估分是否落在范围内，UCAS 本科最多可填 5 个志愿，2027 年入学的多数课程主截止日是 2027 年 1 月 13 日 18:00（英国时间），牛津、剑桥与多数医学、牙医、兽医课程是 2026 年 10 月 15 日。门槛过了，再回到 QS Stars 看它的类别星是不是压在你关心的维度上，比如你在意实习和就业服务，就重点比 Employability 这一栏。国际能见度放在最后看，因为排名更多影响的是回国求职或继续读研时的初始认知。

In practice the order runs from official requirements, to star categories, to visibility. Start with UCAS and the entry requirements published for each course, and check that your A-Level subjects and predicted grades fall inside the range. UCAS allows up to five course choices, and for 2027 entry the main equal consideration deadline is 13 January 2027 at 18:00 UK time, with 15 October 2026 for Oxford, Cambridge and most medicine, dentistry and veterinary courses. Once the requirements line up, return to QS Stars and check whether its category stars sit in the areas you actually care about. If internships and career services matter to you, compare employability carefully. Treat global visibility as the last filter, because rankings mostly shape first impressions when you later apply for jobs or postgraduate study.

六、常见误区：五星不等于最好的大学 / Five Stars Is Not a Trophy

常见的错误是把 5 星当成最好的大学。星级是自我对标的结果：一所学校拿到 5+ 星，说明它在所有类别都达到了 5 星标准，但不代表它比另一所 4 星学校更适合你。另一个误区是把院校星级当成专业实力，评级只在院校与类别层面给结论，不逐专业打分，只有学科排名这个自选类别用来标识它最强的学科方向和认证数量。参评自愿这一点也要记住，一所学校没有星级，往往只是没有参加评估，而不是办学质量差。看的时候顺手确认评估年份，星级是有时间戳的审计结论。很多学生以为星级越高录取就越难，其实两者没有直接关系，录取看的是考试局成绩与课程要求。

The common mistake is reading five stars as the best university overall. A star rating is a self-referenced audit. An institution with five plus stars has met the five-star standard in every category, but that does not make it a better fit for you than a four-star institution. A second error is treating an institutional rating as subject strength. Ratings are given at institution and category level rather than per degree programme, and only the elective subject ranking category signals an institution's strongest subject area and its accreditations. Remember too that participation is voluntary, so a university with no stars may simply have chosen not to be assessed. Check the year of the assessment as well, because a rating is a dated audit conclusion. Many students assume a higher star rating means harder entry, yet admission depends on exam board results and course requirements rather than on stars.

七、2027 年入学申请时间线 / Key Dates for 2027 Entry

2027 年入学的申请季，有几个时间点需要记牢。2026 年 9 月 1 日起可以提交已经完成的本科申请，10 月 15 日是牛津、剑桥与多数医学类课程的截止日，2027 年 1 月 13 日是多数课程的主截止日，2 月 25 日 UCAS Extra 开放，6 月 30 日之后递交的申请会直接进入 Clearing。成绩一侧，JCQ 公布的 2027 年放榜日是 8 月 12 日（A-Level 与 EPQ）和 8 月 19 日（GCSE）。英格兰的资格考试由 Ofqual 监管，评分标准与等级边界由各考试局按 Ofqual 的要求维持，相关信息在 gov.uk 的 Ofqual 页面都能查到。2025 年 A-Level 报考量为 814,335 人次，比 2024 年的 816,890 略低（Ofqual，2025 年 8 月 14 日发布）。

Several dates matter for the 2027 entry cycle. Completed undergraduate applications can be submitted from 1 September 2026, the deadline for Oxford, Cambridge and most medicine courses is 15 October, and the main equal consideration deadline for most courses falls on 13 January 2027. UCAS Extra opens on 25 February, and applications submitted after 30 June 2027 go straight into Clearing. On the results side, JCQ lists 12 August 2027 for A-Level and the Extended Project and 19 August for GCSE. Qualifications in England are regulated by Ofqual, whose pages on gov.uk explain how exam boards maintain standards and set grade boundaries. Ofqual reported 814,335 A-Level entries in 2025, slightly fewer than the 816,890 taken in 2024.

八、教学与就业力两栏，具体看什么数字 / The Numbers Behind the Stars

教学这一栏的星不是印象分，而是按指标折算出来的（QS Stars 方法论 v6.0，2024 版）：师生比从 1:10 拿满分，一路折算到 1:50 拿最低分；一年级升二年级的留存率从 90% 折算到 70%；按期毕业率从 90% 折算到 60%；学生总体满意度与教学满意度从 75% 折算到 50%；本科毕业后 12 个月内继续深造的比例从 30% 折算到 10%；图书馆支出按每名学生 250 美元拿满分、10 美元拿最低分。就业力这一栏更依赖院校提交的就业率数据与雇主声誉调查。看报告时把 4 星拆成这些具体数字，你才知道差距出在师生比、满意度还是就业服务。

Stars in the teaching category are not impressions but scaled indicators, as set out in the QS Stars methodology version 6.0 published in 2024. The faculty-student ratio earns full marks at one faculty member per ten students and the lowest score at one per fifty. Retention from the first year to the second is scaled from 90 per cent down to 70 per cent, and completion within the expected time from 90 per cent down to 60 per cent. Overall student satisfaction and satisfaction with teaching run from 75 per cent down to 50 per cent, and progression to further study within twelve months of graduation from 30 per cent down to 10 per cent. Library spending moves from 250 US dollars per student to a floor of 10 dollars over a twelve-month period. Employability leans more heavily on graduate employment data submitted by the institution and on employer reputation surveys. Breaking a four-star result into these figures shows whether the gap sits in class size, satisfaction or career support.

九、核一份评级前先做三件事 / Three Checks Before You Trust a Rating

核一份评级，可以做三件小事。去 QS 官网的 QS Stars 页面，确认这所学校最近一次评估的年份和它参评的类别清单；再看它做的是哪些自选类别，艺术、创业、多元与包容这类满分 50 分的自选类别拿到 5 星，只说明该方向达标，不代表整体水平；最后把类别星和你要读的课程对齐，课程层面的入学要求、科目组合与考核方式，去 UCAS 和学校官网核对，评级页面不会给你这些。整个流程十分钟左右，能避免把一张营销图当成本科三年的依据。

Three quick checks make a rating usable. Open the QS Stars pages on the QS website and confirm the year of the most recent assessment and the list of categories the institution entered. Note which elective categories were included, because five stars in a 50-point elective area such as arts, entrepreneurship or diversity and inclusion only certifies that area rather than the institution as a whole. Then line the category stars up against the course you want to study. Entry requirements, subject combinations and assessment methods live on UCAS and the university's own pages, and a rating page will not give you any of them. The whole check takes about ten minutes and it stops you from basing three years of undergraduate study on a marketing graphic.

牛津高阶英汉双解词典 第10版 商务印书馆¥168📱 去京东购买京东精选

更多咨询请联系16621398022（同微信）

需要一对一辅导？Need One-on-One Tutoring?

A-Level / GCSE / IB / KS2-KS3 全科辅导

16621398022 同微信

Visit aleveler.com