📚 Year 11 CCEA Philosophy: Case Study Practice in Action | Year 11 CCEA 哲学：案例分析实战演练
Mastering case studies is essential for success in the CCEA GCSE Philosophy ethics exam. This article will guide you through several practical case studies, showing you how to identify moral issues, apply key ethical theories such as Utilitarianism, Kantian Ethics, Situation Ethics, and Natural Law, and construct balanced arguments. You will learn to evaluate different perspectives and reach well-reasoned conclusions, an important skill for high marks. Whether you are tackling medical ethics, animal rights, or war and peace, the practice exercises below will build your confidence.
掌握案例分析对于在 CCEA GCSE 哲学伦理考试中取得成功至关重要。本文将引导你完成几组实战案例，展示如何识别道德问题，运用功利主义、康德伦理学、情境伦理学和自然法理论，并构建平衡的论证。你将学会评估不同观点并得出有理有据的结论，这是获取高分的关键能力。无论你面对的是医学伦理、动物权利还是战争与和平的议题，下面的练习将帮助你建立信心。
1. How to Approach a Case Study | 如何切入案例分析
Before diving into specific cases, you need a clear strategy. First, read the scenario carefully and underline key moral concerns. Ask yourself: who is involved, what rights or duties are at stake, and what consequences might occur? Next, identify the ethical dilemma – often a conflict between two important values. Then, decide which theories you will apply, and make sure you can explain them accurately.
在深入具体案例之前，你需要一个清晰的策略。首先，仔细阅读情境，划出关键的道德关切。问自己：涉及哪些人？有什么权利或义务可能被侵犯？可能产生什么后果？然后，识别伦理困境——通常是两种重要价值之间的冲突。接着，决定你要运用哪些理论，并确保能准确地解释它们。
A good structure for your answer is: (1) Identify the issue and state why it is ethically significant. (2) Apply one or two theories, showing how they would evaluate the situation. (3) Offer critical analysis – discuss strengths and weaknesses of each theory in this context. (4) Conclude with a justified personal judgement, but remember to balance viewpoints. Always use technical terms like 'maxim', 'utility', 'agape', or 'primary precepts' where appropriate.
一个好的答题结构是：(1) 识别问题，并说明为什么它具有伦理意义。(2) 应用一两个理论，展示它们如何评价该情境。(3) 提供批判性分析——讨论每种理论在此背景下的优缺点。(4) 用有理由的个人判断作结论，但要记得平衡各方观点。合适时使用技术术语，如 "准则"、"功利"、"圣爱" 或 "基本诫命"。
2. Case Study 1: Abortion – Scenario & Identification | 案例一：堕胎——情境与识别
Scenario: Sophie is a 16-year-old girl who has just found out she is pregnant after a sexual assault. She lives in a society where abortion is legal up to 24 weeks, but her family is strongly religious and believes that all life is sacred from conception. Sophie is terrified and feels unable to become a mother. She has considered travelling alone to a clinic for an abortion, but fears the emotional and spiritual consequences.
情境：索菲是一名16岁的少女，她刚刚在遭到性侵后发现怀孕了。她生活在一个堕胎在24周以内合法的社会，但她的家庭信仰非常虔诚，认为所有生命从受孕起就是神圣的。索菲感到恐惧，无法成为母亲。她考虑独自前往诊所进行堕胎，但害怕精神和情感上的后果。
The moral dilemma here is the conflict between Sophie's bodily autonomy and mental health on one side, and the sanctity of the potential life of the fetus on the other. Key issues include: Is the fetus a person with a right to life? Does the right to choose override religious beliefs? How do we weigh suffering caused by continuing the pregnancy? Use these questions to guide your analysis.
这里的道德困境是索菲的身体自主权和心理健康与胎儿潜在生命的神圣性之间的冲突。关键问题包括：胎儿是否具有生命权？选择权是否超越宗教信仰？如何衡量继续怀孕所造成的痛苦？用这些问题来引导你的分析。
3.
Published by TutorHao | Year 11 哲学 Revision Series | aleveler.com
更多咨询请联系16621398022（同微信）
或截图后用「扫一扫 → 相册」选择本图